This study investigates how self and other identities are construed in school and family contexts in the narratives of two dyslexic undergraduate students during research interviews granted to the professor-researcher. The theoretical and methodological frameworks belong to the fields of narrative and identity, involving otherness, processes of stigmatization and information manipulation, from a qualitative and interpretativist approach. The procedures that orient the analysis of the construction of self and other are based on constructs such as deixis, self, polyphony and reported discourse. The results of the analysis of the narratives constructed by dyslexic undergraduate students point to not only harmonious and disharmonious relationships within the university environment, but also to conflicts and understandings in the family context, with stigma performances and display. The narratives also highlight intelligibilities on learning disorders, personal needs, and possible ways of overcoming challenges through a reflective, committed and, sometimes, emotional attitude. The purpose of this research is to enrich the studies concerning the relationship among dyslexia, family and school, highlighting the importance of narrative in the research interview as a way of raising reflection, action, changes, from a theoretical and methodological point of view.