According to the theory developed by Kolmogorov, Arnold and Moser in the sixties, the majority of invariant tori persists under a C3 perturbation of a integrable Hamiltonian. A natural question is if a perturbation in the Ck topology, k < 3, still preserves such tori. Bangert showed that, in the C1 topology, what happens is the opposite: there are metrics with no invariant torus arbitrarily close to any given Riemannian metric. Ruggiero extended these results to mechanical Lagrangians in the torus and showed that for Riemannian metrics this phenomenon is C1 generic. In this work, we show that, given e > 0, e 2 R and a reversible Tonelli Hamiltonian H : TT2 -> R, there exists β E (0, 1) and an ǫ perturbation H0 of H in the C1,β topology such that H0 has no continuous invariant graphs. The result is achieved by explicitly exhibiting a Finsler metric, without any continuous field of minimizers, constructed after an analytic study of the Jacobi operator.