Bidirectional selective breeding of a defensive response or any other phenotypic characteristic is a technique in which animals are bred to modify the frequency of the genes that underlie a particular phenotype. Mating animals within a population based on the opposite extremes of an observable characteristic will push, over many generations, this particular phenotype in opposite directions, leading to two separately bred lines. In the present work we employed the conditioned freezing in response to contextual cues previously associated with footshock as the phenotype criterion for developing two new rat lines. The basic protocol consisted of mating male and female albino Wistar rats with the highest and lowest conditioned freezing in response to the contextual cues of the experimental chamber where animals were exposed to three unsignaled electric footshocks on the previous day. Study 1 presents the initial results of fourteen generations of selective breeding. We found that after three generations, reliable differences between these two lines were already present, indicating a strong heritable component of this type of learning. The lines were named Carioca High conditioned Freezing (CHF) and Carioca Low conditioned Freezing (CLF). Also, we introduced a third group of randomly selected animals (RND) in our selective breeding program. In Study 2, we investigated the different patterns of fear extinction and reacquisition in these two new lines. Finally, in Study 3, results showed dissociation between contextual and phasic fear between CHF and CLF rats.