The plugging process of an oil well was analyzed numerically. In this process, the denser fluid is the cement plug, which was placed above the drilling fluid in a vertical well, resulting in an unstable situation. The cement plug was modeled as non-Newtonian and the drilling fluid was considered Newtonian in some cases and non-Newtonian in other cases. The flow solution is studied using the ANSYS Fluent program. The conservation equations were solved using the Finite Volume Method, and the multiphase flow was modeled with the Volume of Fluid method. The non-Newtonian viscoplastic behavior of the cement plug was modeled with the Generalized Newtonian Fluid constitutive equation, with the Herschel-Bulkley viscosity function. The success of the operation was determined by the combination of the governing rheological and geometric parameters. The effect of the governing parameters, such as the density ratio and the viscosity ratio, were investigated for a fixed geometry and a fixed ratio between the cement plug length and diameter. Furthermore, the influence of this ratio in the process was also analyzed while others governing parameters were fixed. It was shown that the flow is highly unstable, and that the governing parameters considerably affect the operation.