The purpose of this study was to compare the impact absorption test of fiber-reinforced composites with natural fibers to expanded polyurethane (PU) foams as a substitute for traditional expanded polystyrene (EPS) in motorcycle helmets, an essential safety item whose primary function is to mitigate the severity of cranial injuries in accidents. This study was principally motivated by the use of polyurethane (PU) due to its adaptable mechanical properties and a simplified mixing process, which enables the incorporation of natural fibers such as coconut, sisal, and sugarcane bagasse into its matrix, in response to the growing environmental challenges and the urgent need for sustainability. The methodology employed included the formulation of composites in varying proportions of selected natural fibers, ranging from 5 to 15 percent, followed by the execution of impact energy absorption tests. The metrological evaluation utilized parametric and non-parametric tools to compare the impact energy absorption results between pure PU composites and those reinforced with selected natural fibers. The results demonstrated a significant improvement in impact energy absorption when using PU composites reinforced with natural fibers. In conclusion, the addition of natural fibers to PU can replace EPS; since, metrologically, there was no detriment to impact energy absorption, in addition to contributing to environmental responsibility.